Donald, I read that you died in the battle of Loos which began on the 18th of September. Your battalion formed part of the 15th Scottish Division, which had only recently been formed. On the day you lost your life the attack was begun at 06.30 hours with an artillery barrage firing gas shells. But the weather that day proved unsuitable, with the wind in the wrong direction and there had been a very heavy fall of rain which made the chalky ground very sticky. We read that the brunt of the attack fell on the 47th London Division and the 15th Scottish Division, and to quote from the report on the fighting: "meanwhile the Highlanders of the new army, the glorious 15th Division, were making their wonderful charge through Loos and over Hill 70. This fierce and rapid spring is probably the finest thing the Highlanders have done throughout their history". It is such a shame that your remains were not recovered from the field of battle, and that thereby you were denied the soldiers grave which you deserved. I agree that it is not the same just to see your name on a large memorial. Donald, we cannot help but admire the courage displayed by you and your comrades. Sincere sympathy to you and your family who mourned your loss. Rest in Peace. Harry.

Henry Harrison